The role of international trade and development
Introduction
This page looks at the role that international trade plays in promoting economic development. Under the old syllabus this page was covered under unit 4.4.Enquiry question
How do each of the following contribute towards economic growth and economic development - import substitution, export promotion, trade liberalization, the role of the WTO, bilateral and regional preferential trade agreements and diversification.
Lesson time: 2 hours (HL) 100 minutes (SL)
Lesson objectives:
With reference to specific examples, evaluate each of the following as a means of achieving economic growth and economic development.
a. Import substitution
b. Export promotion
c. Trade liberalization
d. The role of the WTO
e. Bilateral and regional preferential trade agreements
f. Diversification.
Teacher notes:
1. Beginning activity - begin with the opening video and activity, which focus on import substitution. (Allow 15 minutes in total)
2. Processes - technical vocabulary - the students can learn the background information from the videos, activities 1 and 3 and the key terms which can be downloaded as a PDF. (15 minutes )
3. Applying the theory - activities 2 and 4 focuses on export led growth and uses South Korea as an example, arguably the most successful example of an LEDC developing through an export led strategy. (20 minutes)
4. Developing the theory - activity 5 considers whether the export led model is now impossible due to greater automation in manufacturing. (15 minutes)
5. Enquiry question - what role does the WTO play in development, does it do enough? (10 minutes)
6. Discussion - activities 7 - 8 focus on the question, the role of tourism in development and asks the question, how much is too much tourism? (25 minutes)
7. Case studies - activity 9 contains a paper three type question on Costa Rica, a nation that has benefited financially from its tourism sector - allow 20 minutes to complete the exercise.
Key terms:
Inward looking development strategies (import substitution) - a trade and economic policy which advocates replacing foreign imports with domestic production.
Outward looking development strategies (export promotion) - a trade and economic policy based on prioritising the export of goods for which the nation has a comparative advantage.
Trade liberalisation - the removal or reduction on barriers to trading, including tariffs, quotas and non tariff barriers such as licensing rules and administrative barriers.
Diversification - a policy of steering an economy away from an over reliance on a narrow range of goods and services.
The activities on this page are available as a PDF file at: Development strategies
Activity 1: Inward looking development strategies (import substitution)
Start by watching the following short presentation which describes the policy of import substitution. After watching the video answer the questions that follow:
(a) Summarise the term import substitution.
An import substitution approach is inherently interventionist and protective of domestic markets. This would be achieved by imposing prohibitively high tariffs on imported produce and then subsidising their own domestic industries so that they could replace them.
(b) Explain the strengths of such a policy?
As the video highlights, the policy can protect local jobs, protect local culture and protect an LEDC from the adverse impacts of MNCs.
(c) Explain some of the weaknesses of the policy?
The policy is likely to lead to domestic inefficiency (because local industries are not exposed to foreign competition) and as such may only create jobs in the short term. It also means that the nation is unlikely to benefit from the gains from comparative advantage and inflation is likely to be higher in the country. Other nations are likely to respond to the policy by employing their own tariffs against the nations exports in retaliation.
(d) State some examples of nations that have used import substitution during their development phase.
Many parts of Latin America, Africa and Asia have employed the policy at different times.
Activity 2: Import substitution in Russia
The following news reel documents the story of import substitution in Russia. After watching the video explain why the nation has adopted the policy and explain whether or not the policy is likely to be successful?
Activity 3: Outward looking policies (export promotion)
Begin by watching the short video and then answer the questions that follow:
(a) Summarise the term export led growth.
a trade and economic policy based on prioritising the export of goods for which the nation has a comparative advantage.
(b) Which policies are consistent with an export led development strategy
Liberalised trade and capital policies, a floating exchange rate, deregulation and investment in key infrastructure required to deliver growth.
(c) Explain the strengths of such a policy?
As the video highlights, the policy may allow an economy to break the poverty cycle. Many LEDCs are stuck in a perpetual cycle of low quality products, low skill levels, lack of investment e.t.c. Any business that is able to produce higher quality products will find it almost impossible to sell those goods and services domestically.
(d) Explain some of the weaknesses of the policy?
Led to trade barriers among Developed nations whose own industries were threatened by imports from low wage economies. The policy also meant an increasing share of the economy was controlled by MNCs and lastly the policy led to significant income inequalities.
(e) Why is investment in education and infrastructure key to the successful implementation of the policy?
With exports being the key driver of economic growth then the ability to produce high quality products for export markets was essential. This meant competing with industrialised nations on quality, as well as providing the goods at lower costs.
(f) Why is the policy likely to lead to greater income inequality?
While export led growth has led to some very exceptional growth rates in those nations that have adopted the policy, such a policy will create losers as well as winners. Some, perhaps the old, unskilled or geographically immobile can easily be left behind by such a policy.
(g) State some examples of nations that have used import substitution during their development phase.
Japan, South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan.
Activity 4: A focus on South Korea
Use information contained in the following video to explain how South Korea used export promotion to support its own development. Why did the policy seem risky at the time?
Activity 5: Premature de-industrialisation
Use the information contained in the following video to answer the questions that follow:
(a) What is premature industrialisation?
When an economy effectively skips the secondary phase of development and moves directly from being an agriculturally based economy to a service based one.
(b) Why are manufacturing jobs considered more important than service or agricultural jobs?
Manufactured jobs are easier to create export growth, improvements to technology and greater productivity through investments in human and technical sectors.
(c) Why has automation restricted the ability of LEDCs to develop through export led growth as South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan were able to do?
Automation has reduced the need for low wage workers which has removed some of the previous comparative advantage that ambitious low wage economies once had.
(d) What is the future of development and growth according to the video?
Opinion is mixed, some economists are particularly negative, believing that the chances of the next ambitious LEDC being the next South Korea have effectively gone. On the other hand the video also argues some nations may be able to benefit from the access to cheap technological goods and be able to develop quickly as a result. An example fo this is how cell phone coverage across Africa has played a role in connecting that continent.
Activity 6: The role of the WTO in promoting development?
The first video explains the role of the WTO and the role that the current round of talks in Daha might play in promoting development within LEDCs?
Activity 7: The role of tourism in development
The following video illustrates some of the costs and benefits that tourism can bring to an LEDC. The video focuses on Thailand.
(a) Explain some of the benefits that tourism has brought to the island nation.
Billion of $s in export revenue through tourism and the creation of masses of new jobs and improvements to infrastructure.
(b) Explain why the high income elasticity of the industry makes the industry more suitable for promoting development than a reliance on the export of primary products.
Unlike the production of primary commodities, which many LEDCs have used as a development tool, tourism is highly income elastic. This allows an LEDC to take advantage of rising income levels and increased demand for new exotic holiday destinations.
(c) Why does the tourist industry bring about infrastructure improvements to a nation?
A nation wishing to attract large number of tourists must ensure that the nation is equipped with adequate air, road and communications infrastructure. Such improvements, built for the tourist sector, can then be used by local residents.
(d) Outline some of the disadvantages that tourism can bring to an LEDC.
Tourists drive up prices for local customers and can destroy / retard areas of natural beauty as the video highlights, hence the focus by some nations on ethical / sustainable tourism.
The table below illustrates the % of GDP contributed by the tourist sector:
Nation | Revenue earned (B$) | % of GDP |
Macau | 43 | 73 |
Seychelles | 1,054 | 67 |
Maldives | 3,521 | 66.4 |
St. Kitts | 636 | 62.4 |
Grenada | 676 | 56.5 |
(e) Explain the danger of an over reliance on tourism for an LEDC?
Tourism can be an unstable, if highly profitable, source of income due to changing external circumstances. The once popular beaches of Turkey and north Africa, for example are now virtually empty due to security fears in the region.
Activity 8: How much is too much tourism?
Watch the following short video and then answer the question, how much is too much tourism?
Activity 9: Tourism in Costa Rica paper three type questions (HL only)
Costa Rica is one of the leading destinations for foreign visitors in the central American region. In 2019 the number of tourists visiting the small central American nation reached 2.88 million. This represented a market share of 26.4% of all tourists to the region. Costa Rica has a population of 4.7 million inhabitants and a per capita GDP of $ 16,900.
The growth in tourist numbers is shown as follows:
Year | Tourist visitors in thousands | Income generated in million $s |
2014 | 2,100 | 1,999 |
2015 | 2,192 | 2,152 |
2016 | 2,343 | 2,313 |
2017 | 2,428 | 2,665 |
2018 | 2,527 | 2,864 |
2019 | 2,665 | 2,882 |
1. Calculate the % growth in tourist numbers and income generated between 2014 and 2019? [2 marks]
The growth in tourist numbers is 26.9% while the growth in revenue is 44.17%.
2. Redraw the table above showing the tourist numbers and income generated as an index. Use the figures for 2014 as the base year. [3 marks]
Year | Tourist visitors in thousands | Income generated in million $s |
2014 | 100 | 100 |
2015 | 104.4 | 107.6 |
2016 | 111.57 | 115.7 |
2017 | 115.6 | 133.3 |
2018 | 120.3 | 143.3 |
2019 | 126.9 | 144.2 |
3. Show the impact of the rise in tourist numbers to Costa Rica on the diagram below: [2 marks]
A rise in overseas visitors to the country will increase both LRAS as well as AD. In other words both the productive capacity of the nation as well as overall economic activity will increase.
4. Outline three advantages to Costa Rica, a developing country of using tourism as a method for generating economic growth. [4 marks]
The benefits of tourism, as a source of economic growth / development include:
- tourism is highly income elastic which, unlike many other goods and services where LEDCs may have a comparative advantage, allows the country to take advantage of rising income levels
- increased job creation as the industry is labour intensive
- a valuable source of foreign currency which can then be used to import much needed capital, required for development
- developing a tourist industry requires investments in infrastructure which can then be used by local residents as well as visitors to the island.
The disadvantages of tourism as a development strategy include:
- a significant proportion of revenue received goes to overseas travel agents and the owners of hotels who may also live overseas
- tourists will spend a large proportion of their holiday money on imported goods and services
- negative externalities associated with tourism, e.g. the costs of overcrowded beaches or areas of natural beauty
- additional pressure on local infrastructure
- tourist numbers can also be an unstable due to changing external circumstances.
The paper three question is available as a PDF file at: P3 question on Costa Rica
Mark scheme: Costa Rica