InThinking Revision Sites

INTHINKING REVISION SITES

Own your learning

Why not also try our independent learning self-study & revision websites for students?

We currenly offer the following DP Sites: Biology, Chemistry, English A Lang & Lit, Maths A&A, Maths A&I, Physics, Spanish B

"The site is great for revising the basic understandings of each topic quickly. Especially since you are able to test yourself at the end of each page and easily see where yo need to improve."

"It is life saving... I am passing IB because of this site!"

Basic (limited access) subscriptions are FREE. Check them out at:

Below the line promotion

Below the line promotion (AO2)

Below the line (BTL) promotion refers to marketing activities which the organization has direct control over. It is aimed directly at a targeted audience instead of a general audience (as is the case for ATL promotional strategies). Unlike above the line (ATL) strategies, BTL promotional strategies do not use mass media platforms such as television, newspapers, radio, and magazines.

 ATL Activity 1 (Thinking and Research skills) - Logos, Slogans, and Promotion

Most businesses use corporate slogans as a form of promotion, perhaps to inform, persuade and/or remind customers about their products (such as KFC's Finger Lickin' Good) or or inspire customers (such as Honda's The Power of Dreams).

  • Design a new logo and/or slogan for your school.

  • Be prepared to explain your reason(s) to the class.

Extension task

The Coca-Cola Company was founded in 1886 and has use a large number of corporate slogans as part of its marketing campaigns. The company has used six different corporate slogans in the 21st Century:

  • 2000 - Coca-Cola. Enjoy

  • 2001 - Life Tastes Good

  • 2003 - Coca-Cola... Real

  • 2005 - Make It Real

  • 2006 - The Coke Side of Life

  • 2009 - Open Happiness

Read this article from the company's website to find out more about the history of The Coca-Cola Company's advertising slogans by clicking the link here.

 Theory of Knowledge (TOK) - Unethical advertising slogans?

Businesses often make unsubstantiated marketing claims / slogans about their products. Some examples are shown below:

  • The ultimate driving machine – BMW

  • The world's favourite airline – British Airways

  • Probably the best lager in the world – Carlsberg beer

  • Open Happiness – Coca-Cola

  • Helps prevent colds and flu – Dannon’s Activia yoghurt

  • The happiest place on earth – Disneyland theme resorts

  • Keeps going and going and going – Energizer batteries

  • Put a Tiger in your tank – Esso petrol

  • The best a man can get – Gillette shaving products

  • It wouldn't be home without Hellmann's – Hellmann’s sauces

  • Prevent and cure sore throats – Listerine mouth wash

  • Tastes so good cats ask for it by name – Meow Mix cat food

  • One bite and all your dreams will come true – Nutella chocolate and hazelnut spread

  • Your hair will outshine the sun this summer – Pantene shampoo

  • There is no substitute – Porsche

  • Once You Pop, You Can't Stop – Pringles’ crisps (potato chips)

  • Red Bull gives you wings – Red Bull energy drink

  • Taste the Rainbow – Skittles

  1. Discuss the extent to which marketing slogans distort knowledge, so are deemed to be unethical.

  2. Discuss the extent to which unsubstantiated marketing claims (marketing messages), such as those listed above, are socially and culturally acceptable.

In the discussions, consider whether people in society intuitively 'know' that these marketing claims are unproven so such statements are harmless and therefore ethically acceptable.

Encourage students to provide examples of their own.

It might also be worth noting that Red Bull was sued for $13m for false advertising in 2014. The famous energy drink slogan "Red Bull gives you wings" was found to be misleading and dishonest after a US lawsuit.

Extension tasks

  1. Find other examples of unsubstantiated marketing claims in your country, or a country of your choice.

  1. Evaluate the extent to which business organizations in your country, or the country of your choice, have an ethical and moral responsibility to use only substantiated claims in their marketing.

 ATL Activity 2 (Research and Thinking skills) - The language of promotion

This activity has been created and contributed by my esteemed colleague, Dr. Rima Puri.

All businesses rely on some form of promotion to communicate with their customers in an attempt to inform about the product and/or to persuade customers to buy. The promotional mix includes a range of above the line and below the line methods to achieve the marketing objectives of an organization.

The selection of the right words (language) in marketing is crucial. The choice of words attracts the attention and converts the prospects or benefits to clients. There is an art to marketing, and it is important to use the right words to convey the right messages.

The table below shows seven powerful words often used in marketing.

WordMeaning
YouPersonal marketing is all about the customers
EasyHassle free purchase
QualityHigh value and safe to use
BestMost excellent or desirable type
FreeHard to resist a freebie
GuaranteeRemoves doubt
Don't miss (out)Optimize on fear of missing out (FOMO)

Tasks

(a)Work with a partner in class and take turns to explain to one another the key terms in bold.
(b)Using secondary sources, find 5 examples of businesses that use any five of the  words mentioned above.
(c)Using your response to part (b), identify if these promotional methods are informative or persuasive.
 Teacher only box

Answers

(a)  Work with a partner in class and take turns to explain to one another the key terms in bold.

  • Promotion is the act of communicating with actual or potential customers in an attempt to inform about the product or business and to persuade them to buy.
  • Above the line promotion involves the use of mass media sources such as television, radio advertising, cinema, newspaper advertising, magazines, outdoor advertising, etc.

  • Below the line promotion includes the use of non-mass media promotional activities such as branding, slogans, logos, packaging, word of mouth promotion, direct marketing, sales promotion, point of sales promotion, publicity, sponsorship, etc.

  • Marketing objectives are the goals of the marketing department in order to achieve consumer satisfaction whilst maximizing profits for the organization.

(b)  Using secondary sources, find 5 examples of businesses that use any five of the  words mentioned above.

Answers will vary depending on the research conducted by students.

(c)  Using your response to part (b), identify if these promotional methods are informative or persuasive.

Answers will vary depending on the research conducted by students.

Whilst the Business Management guide does not specify particular examples of BTL promotional methods, typical platforms used by businesses include: (1) direct mail, (2) public relations (PR), (3) sponsorship deals, (4) point of sale promotion, (5) email, (6) customer loyalty programmes, (7) merchandising, (8) exhibitions (trade fairs), and (9) sales promotions.

1.  Direct mail

Direct mail refers to the use of postal correspondence for promotional purposes. Examples include the use of newsletters, letters, postcards, brochures and catalogues sent through the post to targeted customers to keep them informed and to persuade them to make purchases. It is usually used to target specific market segments and aims to encourages customers to buy directly from the business organization.A drawback of using direct mail is the potentially high costs of administration and postage. Also, many customers regard direct mail as junk mail (spam) so a lot of the advertising materials get disposed of without customers paying attention to the marketing messages. Although direct mail is applicable to almost all businesses, the sheer amount of promotional information sent through the post can create advertising clutter, thus making it difficult for a particular advert to stand out.

2.  Public relations (PR)

Edward Bernays (1891-1995), considered as the father of public relations, defined the concept as the “management function which tabulates public attitudes, defines the policies, procedures and interest of an organisation followed by executing a program of action to earn public understanding and acceptance.”

Examples of public relations activities include:

  • Publicity events

  • Speeches to targeted groups and professional organizations (such as seminars and receptions)

  • Talk show appearances (radio or TV)

  • Books and other writings

  • Direct communication (such as Newsletters or email)

  • Blogs and vlogs

  • Social media, such as Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, and Facebook

  • Working with the Press / news media.

Public relations helps to develop positive relationships with the press, media and general public. It can also be a highly cost effective method of promotion, especially if the new media provides free coverage of a positive story about the business. However, this is not always the case; some businesses use celebrities or famous people to endorse their organization or brands as a form of public relations.

Whilst many firms have specialists to communicate positive news with the press, journalists and news media often report an amended version of the story. Despite the efforts (time and money) needed to put a good story together for the press, there is no assurance that they will run the story.

 ATL Activity 3 (Thinking skills) - What do we know about PR?

To consolidate your understanding of the role of PR, read this article from Forbes magazine titled “Five Things Everyone Should Know About Public Relations”.

3.  Sponsorship deals

Sponsorship is a BTL promotional strategy that involves a business providing financial support (the sponsor) to another organization or event. For the sponsor, there can be huge marketing advantages of being associated with the sponsored event or organization. For example, Adidas sponsors the FIFA World Cup (football or soccer), and Coca-Cola sponsors the Olympic Games. Televised broadcasts of these sporting events give Adidas and Coca-Cola exposure to a global audience. Note that the sponsors do not pay for television adverts during the event (which would be classified as above the line promotion).

Sponsorship deals can provide a long-term source of finance for organizations. For example, Arsenal Football Club in London received a €132 million sponsorship deal in 2006, lasting 15-year with Emirates Airline. In November 2012, this was extended with another £150m deal to extend shirt sponsorship until 2019 and naming rights to the Emirates Stadium until 2028. Other airlines that sponsor top football clubs include Etihad Airways (Manchester City Football Club), Qatar Airways (Barcelona Football Club) and South African Airways (Sunderland Football Club).

Which football club has the most lucrative football shirt sponsorship deal? Take a look at this website to find out...

 Take a look at this short video clip about the history of football shirt sponsorship – it is interesting to see how things have changed since the 1970s:

However, negative behaviour of the sponsor could harm the organization’s reputation. For example, Volkswagen’s heavy investment in football sponsorship deals became questionable after its emissions scandal was exposed in late 2015. According to Soccer 365, VW sponsors about 18 of the 36 football clubs in Germany’s top two leagues, including football giants Wolfsburg and Bayern Munich.

Also, sponsorship deals can be very expensive (see examples of football clubs above). A recent report in Business Insider also showed that over half of brands that people associated with Euro 2016 were not even official sponsors of Europe’s most lucrative sporting event! Read the article here.

  Click on the following hyperlink to watch a short video clip of the official sponsors of the FIFA World Cup 2022 and see how many sponsors you recognise.

 Key concept - Ethics

Discuss why the world's most valuable sports clubs, such as Real Madrid Football Club and the New York Yankees, would not want or accept sponsorship deals from tobacco companies.

 Teacher only box

Possible discussion points could include consideration of such unethical action (placing profits before people) and how this is likely to negatively affect the corporate image of the sports clubs which, directly or indirectly, promote healthy lifestyles. In addition, these sporting organizations are likely to have a young fan base, thus any association with harmful products such as tobacco would not be socially (or ethically) acceptable for the vast majority of their sporting fans.
 

4.  Point of sale promotion

Supermarkets are experts at using point of sale

Point of sale (POS) is the promotion of goods in retail outlets where customers can buy the goods. Promotional materials are positioned in order to provide convenience and easy access for customers thus encouraging customers to make impulse purchases.

For example, supermarket use highly visible promotional materials in their supermarket aisles to attract customers with special offers. They also place snacks, batteries, candy and other small items at the checkouts as a last attempt to make more sales whilst customers queue to pay for the items in their baskets or trolleys.

5.  Email

Electronic mail (e-mail) is the use of Internet technologies used to send and receive electronic messages and attachments. It continues to be a popular form of below-the-line promotion. The Internet provides a highly cost effective way for businesses to reach a potentially global audience. Email promotion is environmentally friendly as paper and postage are not required, yet it is more cost effective than direct mail.

However, there can be complications with the use of email for promotional purposes. For example, many customers perceive emails as unsolicited marketing messages (known as online spam). In many countries, there may also be legal issues surrounding the use and storage of private data.

6.  Customer loyalty programmes

Customer loyalty schemes reward those who make repurchases. Customers who are members of the loyalty programme can accumulate points to qualify for price discounts and free gifts. This BTL strategy also enables the business organization to gain access to customer data and details which can be used for direct marketing purposes (such as direct mail). The strategy can be applied to almost all businesses and industries, e.g. airline companies, cinemas, hotels, restaurants and retailers.

However, customer loyalty programmes can be expensive to operate (such as the cost of offering price discounts, the free gifts and administrative costs).

 Case Study 1 - Customer Loyalty Schemes

A popular way that supermarkets and other retailers use to compete is through the use of customer loyalty schemes. The use of loyalty schemes offer customers special offers and discounts depending on the number of points accrued. For example, supermarkets offer price discounts for members, whilst cinemas offer free tickets and/or movie snacks for their loyal customers.

Customer loyalty schemes can be a highly effective way to ensure customers keep coming back and make repeat purchases.

 ATL Activity 4 - Customer loyalty programmes

Examine the use of customer loyalty programmes as a strategy for an organization of your choice. For example, you could consider one of the following industries: airlines, supermarkets, restaurants, or coffee shops.

Consider the costs, benefits, and potential competitive advantages of the customer loyalty scheme for the chosen organization.

 ATL Activity 5 - The Economist

Read this article from The Economist about the growing importance and use of customer loyalty schemes in the hotel industry here. To what extent are customer loyalty schemes an effective form of below the line promotion?

7.  Merchandising

Supermarkets are experts at using merchandising

Merchandising is the selling of a firm’s own products as a form of BTL promotion for the business and/or its brands. Merchandise refers to a retailer’s range of goods that are available for sale. Merchandising involves strategies to display the organization’s products in such a way so as to stimulate demand. This can help to entice customers to make impulse (unplanned) purchases.

However, the use of merchandising to promote a firm or its products incurs additional costs, such the costs of stock control systems. Some retailers, such as supermarkets, use a lot of merchandising but this often leads to visual advertising clutter within the aisles or store. Merchandising is also commonly used by operators of amusement parks (theme parks) such as Universal Studios and the Walt Disney Company.

8.  Exhibitions (trade fairs)

A trade fair is where specialist firms exhibit their goods and services for sale to potential customers, both private clients and business customers. It is a form of promotion where a captured audience visit the exhibitions, so trade fairs provide good opportunities to network with potential clients.

Trade fairs provide opportunities for customers and consumers to see new products first-hand before these are launched onto the market. Potential customers and consumers can also provide valuable feedback for the business.

Being trade fairs (as the name suggests), these are not always open to the general public. They are usually attended by business representatives (i.e. members of the trade) plus members of the press / media. They are widely used in a range of industries, including:

  • Books

  • Computers / Consumer electronics

  • Flowers / Floristry

  • Homes  / Home improvements

  • Jewellery

  • Cars / Motor vehicles

  • Champagne / Wines

  • Healthcare / healthcare products

  • Textiles

  • Video games

However, as trade fairs involve competitors from the same industry, there is usually strong competition from rivals exhibiting at these events. There is also limited space to display all of the firm’s products. Finally, trade fairs do not occur very often so these must be used in conjunction with other promotional activities.

 Exam Practice Question

Outline why trade fairs are classified as a method of below the line promotion.     [2 marks]

 Teacher only box

Below the line (BTL) promotion refers to marketing activities of an organization which it has direct control over but does not reach a mass market audience. Trade shows are a form of BTL promotion that uses exhibition booths and venues to target their marketing directly at a captured audience instead of a general audience. Trade shows or trade exhibitions.

Award [1 mark] for showing an understanding of BTL promotion, and another [1 mark] for the link to show how trade fairs are such an example.

9.  Sales promotions

Sales promotion is a short term promotional tactic used to entice customers to buy a certain product. It is a temporary measure to boost sales using methods such as:

  • Free samples / free gifts

  • Money off coupons (vouchers)

  • Discount vouchers

  • Buy one get one free offers

  • Prize competitions

Sales promotion is often used to encourage customers to trial a new product or to entice them to switch from a rival brand.

The main drawback of sales promotion is that it is costly to maintain, i.e. it is only a short-term method to increase sales volume. Also, customers may come to expect or anticipate further sales promotions (thereby delaying their purchase).

Key terms

  • Below the line (BTL) promotion refers to marketing activities which the organization has direct control over. It is aimed directly at a targeted audience instead of a general audience. Unlike ATL strategies, BTL promotional strategies do not use the mass media.

  • Customer loyalty schemes are a form of BTL promotional method that rewards those who make repurchases. Customers who are members of the loyalty program can accumulate points to qualify for price discounts and free gifts.

  • Direct mail refers to the use of postal correspondence for promotional purposes, such as the use of newsletters, letters, postcards, brochures, and catalogues.

  • Electronic mail (e-mail) is the use of Internet technologies used to send and receive electronic messages and attachments.

  • Merchandising is the selling of a firm’s own products as a form of BTL promotion for the business and/or its brands.

  • Point of sale (POS) is the promotion of goods in retail outlets where customers can buy the goods.

  • Public relations (PR) refers to the management function of actions that earn public understanding and acceptance, such as publicity events and press conferences.

  • Sales promotion is a short-term promotional tactic used to entice customers to buy a certain product. It is a temporary measure to boost sales.

  • Sponsorship is a BTL promotional strategy that involves a business providing financial support (the sponsor) to another organization or event.

  • A trade fair is where specialist firms exhibit their goods and services for sale to potential customers, both private clients and business customers.

ATL vs BTL Promotion Quiz

There are 15 promotional methods listed in the table below. Identify whether each of the following is an example of above the line promotion (ATL) or below the line promotion (BTL).

Promotional method

ATL or BTL?

1.  Logos

BTL promotion

2.  Free samples

BTL promotion

3.  Pamphlets

BTL promotion

4. Branding

BTL promotion

5.  Special offers

BTL promotion

6.  Magazine advertising

ATL promotion

7.  Cinema advertising

ATL promotion

8.  Internet advertising, e.g. Google and Facebook

ATL promotion

9.  Newspaper advertising

ATL promotion

10. Merchandising

BTL promotion

11. Packaging

BTL promotion

12. Television advertising

ATL promotion

13. Advertising on public transport, e.g., buses and trains

ATL promotion

14. Catchphrases and corporate slogans

BTL promotion

15. Trade publications

ATL promotion

Return to the Unit 4.5 - The seven Ps of the marketing mix homepage

Return to the Unit 4 - Marketing homepage