Insolvency versus bankruptcy
"An expenditure of words without income of ideas will lead to intellectual bankruptcy."
- Ravi Zacharias (1946 - 2020), author and religious leader
Insolvency refers to the situation where a person or a business is unable to meet their bill and other debt obligations. The debts (liabilities) of the individual or organization exceed their assets. The situation, if not managed effectively, can result in legal action being taken against the insolvent individual or business, with assets being liquidated (seized and sold) to pay off as much of the outstanding debts as possible.
Situations that can cause insolvency include:
A cash flow crisis caused by overspending (cash outflows) or debtors (trade customers) who are late paying.
Loss of customers who have switched to a competitor's good or service due to changing needs and market trends.
Loss of an important supplier that accounts for significant cost savings.
Financial mismanagement.
Global and local supply chain issues that prevent the business from being able to trade.
It is usually illegal for a firm to continue trading as an insolvent entity. A common solution to insolvency is declaring bankruptcy.
Bankruptcy (sometimes referred to receivership or corporate liquidation) means a situation when a person or business declares that they can no longer pay back their debts, so the entity collapses (fails). Once the person or firm's assets are liquidated to pay off some of the debts, an independent organization takes charge of legal proceedings to administer the bankruptcy, including contacting their trade creditors and financiers, as well as investigating the affairs of the individual or organization. Once a business is officially declared as bankrupt, its creditors can no longer demand payments from the business, charge it interest on outstanding debts, or take further legal action against the organization. Any outstanding debts can then be written off.
The difference between insolvency and bankruptcy is that the former describes a state of financial distress whereas the latter refers to a legal declaration and legal processes culminating in a conclusion. Not all insolvencies will lead to bankruptcies.
The COVID-19 pandemic caused many businesses to go bankrupt
In the case of limited liability companies, if a company goes into bankruptcy and owes money to individuals, commercial banks, and other creditors, the shareholders of the company do not have to pay any of those debts (as they have limited liability). The liability of shareholders is simply limited to their investment in the company. However, the shareholders are the last party to receive any funds from the sale of the firm's assets once and if all debts have been paid first.
Table 1 - Differences between insolvency and bankruptcy
Insolvency | Bankruptcy |
The financial state when a firm is unable to pay its debts to creditors due to insufficient funds and assets | The legal state when a firm is unable to pay off debts, i.e., legal procedures after being declared insolvent |
Symptoms include falling sales, rising debts, and poor net cash flow, and deficient liquidity ratios | Symptoms include indebtedness and insolvency |
Insolvency does not affect the legal status of an individual or a business, at least in the short-term. | Bankruptcy affects the legal status of an individual or a firm, as bankruptcy leads to permanent closure |
It does not impact the credit rating of an individual or a business (all firms can experience insolvency issues) | It negatively impacts the credit rating of an individual or a firm due to bankruptcy being used as a last resort |
Can be resolved through measures that improve liquidity or through bankruptcy | Can be resolved by winding up (liquidating) the business, which will then cease to exist |
It is not permanent nor final, so the issues can be resolved | It is permanent, and results in the business selling off its assets |
An alternative approach to liquidation (the sales of a firm’s assets to repay its debts) is voluntary administration. This involves the appointment of a third party (the voluntary administrator or independent registered liquidator) that takes full control of the business with the intended purpose of saving it. Depending on the laws of the country, this may occur before bankruptcy or once bankruptcy has been declared. It involves the third party administrator renegotiating with the firm's creditors (such as suppliers and banks), cost cutting, and other techniques to allow the business to return to solvency.
Video Review
Watch this video documentary about the history, success, and eventual bankruptcy of Kodak as the company, founded in 1892, failed to maintain its market presence in the photography industry. There are accompanying questions below for you to answer as you watch the video.
Questions
Founded in 1892, in which year did Kodak file for bankruptcy? 2012
What year did George Eastman envision a simple, easy to use camera? 1877
How old was George Eastman when he opened his first factory? 26 years old
What was the name of the revolutionary product that Eastman made, 8 years after opening his factory? Kodak
During World War I, what did the Kodak Company develop in attempts to aid the war? Aerial photographing technology
Who was the longtime collaborator of George Eastman? Henry A. Strong
After World War II, what demographic did Kodak relocate its entire focus on? Average consumers (mass market)
What is the name of the astronaut who first recorded space travel through video? John Glenn
Shortly after the 1965 World's Fair, Kodak had surpassed what number of employees? 100,000
What was the value of Kodak's sales revenue after its large presence at the 1965 World's Fair? Over $4 billion
Which Japanese firm was seen as a high status competitor to Kodak in the 1990s? Fujifilm
Kodak's sales revenue peaked at which figure? $16.3 billion
How many digital cameras were sold in 2007? 28 million
What factor played a significant role in the reduction of Kodak sales? Advancements in smartphone technologies
What was the date of Kodak's filing for bankruptcy? January 19th 2012
How much was the bankruptcy filing, made with Citigroup, worth? $950 million
After its bankruptcy, what type of product did Kodak fully focus on? Printing devices
How much profit did Kodak generate in the 2019 fiscal year? $116 million
What decade did Kodak develop its first digital camera? 1970s
What went wrong for the Kodak, in terms of its failure to keep to George Eastman's claim that the company would always be on the cutting edge of technology? Whilst true for over a century, the company lost sight of Kodak's original innovation mindset and became blind to the revolutionary digital age (of digital cameras and smartphones)
Answers
Timings have been included for teachers' reference
1:06 Founded in 1892, in which year did Kodak file for bankruptcy? 2012
1:27 What year did George Eastman envision a simple, easy to use camera? 1877
2:00 How old was George Eastman when he opened his first factory? 26 years old
2:22 What was the name of the revolutionary product that Eastman made, 8 years after opening his factory? Kodak
2:53 During World War I, what did the Kodak Company develop in attempts to aid the war? Aerial photographing technology
3:04 Who was the longtime collaborator of George Eastman? Henry A. Strong
4:22 After World War II, what demographic did Kodak relocate its entire focus on? Average consumers (mass market)
4:40 What is the name of the astronaut who first recorded space travel through video? John Glenn
4:56 Shortly after the 1965 World's Fair, Kodak had surpassed what number of employees? 100,000
5:03 What was the value of Kodak's sales revenue after its large presence at the 1965 World's Fair? Over $4 billion
5:56 Which Japanese firm was seen as a high status competitor to Kodak in the 1990s? Fujifilm
7:07 Kodak's sales revenue peaked at which figure? $16.3 billion
9:22 How many digital cameras were sold in 2007? 28 million
10:26 What factor played a significant role in the reduction of Kodak sales? Advancements in smartphone technologies
11:51 What was the date of Kodak's filing for bankruptcy? January 19th 2012
12:06 How much was the bankruptcy filing, made with Citigroup, worth? $950 million
12:46 After its bankruptcy, what type of product did Kodak fully focus on? Printing devices
13:46 How much profit did Kodak generate in the 2019 fiscal year? $116 million
14:50 What decade did Kodak develop its first digital camera? 1970s
16:50 What went wrong for the Kodak, in terms of its failure to keep to George Eastman's claim that the company would always be on the cutting edge of technology? Whilst true for over a century, the company lost sight of Kodak's original innovation mindset and became blind to the revolutionary digital age (of digital cameras and smartphones)
Case Study - Lego
Lego was founded in 1932 and up to 1998 had never experienced a loss. However, by 2003 the privately held company had debts of $800m. Read this case study from The Guardian to find out how the Danish company turned a loss into profit and to overtake Ferrari the world’s most powerful brand at the time. There are accompanying questions for you to answer as you read the article.
Questions
Since its founding in 1932, what had Lego never experienced for 66 years?
Consultants suggested to Lego to look to which American toy manufacturer to diversify Lego's product portfolio of (just) toy bricks?
How much did Lego's theme parks costing to build?
How much did Lego's theme parks earn during their first year?
Despite not having an experience, what type of business did Lego build from scratch?
In which year did the Lego Group overtake Ferrari to become the world's most powerful brand?
What happened to Lego's profits between 2008 - 2010?
Which organization voted Lego as the toy of the century?
Which year was the Lego Movie released?
Which movie did better at the box office - The Lego Batman Movie or Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice?
How many bricks are made at Lego’s production plant in Billund every day?
Legoland theme parks in the UK are owned by which company?
Winners of Lego Ideas submissions, a crowdsourcing competition, receive what percentage of their product's net sales?
In 2011, what percentage of Lego's customer base was made up of boys/males?
How many years of research did Lego Friends take?
What did the family of the Lego Group invest into in 1946, despite advice against it?
When was Lego's "System" created (allow every brick to connect and everything being backwards compatible)?
A mathematician recently deduced that just six eight-stud bricks of the same color could be combined in how many different ways?
What is the connecting power of Lego referred to as?
What is Lego Life?
Answers
Since its founding in 1932, what had Lego never experienced for 66 years? A loss
Consultants suggested to Lego to look to which American toy manufacturer to diversify Lego's product portfolio of (just) toy bricks? Mattel
How much did Lego's theme parks costing to build? £125m ($155m)
How much did Lego's theme parks earn during their first year? A loss of £25m ($33m)
Despite not having an experience, what type of business did Lego build from scratch? It built its own video games company
In which year did the Lego Group overtake Ferrari to become the world's most powerful brand? 2015
What happened to Lego's profits between 2008 - 2010? They quadrupled
Which organization voted Lego as the toy of the century? The British Toy Retailers Association
Which year was the Lego Movie released? 2014
Which movie did better at the box office - The Lego Batman Movie or Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice? The Lego Batman Movie
How many bricks are made at Lego’s production plant in Billund every day? 120m bricks a day!
Legoland theme parks in the UK are owned by which company? Merlin Entertainments
Winners of Lego Ideas submissions, a crowdsourcing competition, receive what percentage of their product's net sales? 1%
In 2011, what percentage of Lego's customer base was made up of boys/males? 90%
How many years of research did Lego Friends take? Four years
What did the family of the Lego Group invest into in 1946, despite advice against it? Plastic-injection moulding machine
When was Lego's "System" created (allow every brick to connect and everything being backwards compatible)? 1958
A mathematician recently deduced that just six eight-stud bricks of the same color could be combined in how many different ways? 915,103,765
What is the connecting power of Lego referred to as? Clutch Power
What is Lego Life? Social network for kids too young for Instagram to share their creations
Key concept - Ethics
Discuss how accounting for and reporting of an organization's triple bottom line (economic, social, and environmental sustainability) can support the shift towards more ethical business practices.
Bankruptcy (also known as receivership or liquidation) refers to the situation when a person or business declares that they can no longer pay back their debts, so the entity collapses (fails).
Insolvency refers to the situation where a person or a business is unable to meet their bill and other debt obligations.
Voluntary administration is an alternative to liquidation and involves a third party takings full control of the business with the intention of rescuing it.
To test your understanding of the differences between insolvency and bankruptcy, have a go at this true or false quiz.
Statement | True of False? | |
1. | Bankruptcy is a legal proceeding that involves an individual or business entity unable to repay their outstanding debts (liabilities). | True |
2. | In the case of bankruptcy, assets are recorded and valued, with these assets then used to repay outstanding debts. | True |
3. | Firms that are insolvent do not have to pay off any of their liabilities (debts). | False |
4. | A business that does not have sufficient accessible cash to pay its debts, can go into liquidation. | True |
5. | Insolvency is the inability to receive debts when they are due. | False - it is the inability to pay debts when they are due |
6. | Insolvency and indebtedness are indicators of bankruptcy. | True |
7. | Insolvency occurs when the value of a firm's net assets is less than the value of its net current liabilities. | True - insolvency exists if a firm cannot repay debts from its assets |
8. | Insolvency is the legal declaration of an entity's inability to pay off its debts. | False - this refers to bankruptcy |
9. | Insolvency does not impact the credit rating of an individual or an organization. | True - this is because insolvency is neither permanent nor final |
10. | It is possible for a business to resolve insolvency issues through bankruptcy. | True - if measures to improve liquidity fail, it can file for bankruptcy |
Return to the Unit 3.6 - Efficiency ratio analysis (HL only) homepage
Return to the Unit 3 - Finance & Accounts homepage